Rob Murphy on Team 1040 this morning

The Place for BC Lion Discussion. A forum for Lions fans to talk and chat about our team.
Discussion, News, Information and Speculation regarding the BC Lions and the CFL.
Prowl, Growl and Roar!

Moderator: Team Captains

User avatar
joesports
All Star
Posts: 443
Joined: Sat Sep 01, 2007 9:35 am
Location: Section 241 with a great view

Soundy wrote:A work in progress...

Image

:lol: Maybe it should say "whining is our strategy" rather than quality is our recipe. :lol:
Shaggy
Starter
Posts: 228
Joined: Sun Sep 23, 2007 11:02 pm
Location: Maple Ridge, BC

Tape a $1000 bill over his mouth while you're at it :lol:
TheLionKing
Hall of Famer
Posts: 25542
Joined: Sat Feb 19, 2005 10:13 pm
Location: Vancouver

OrangeShoes99 wrote:Tillman knows Murphy is an integral part of the team. He was trying to get him suspended, period.

Abdullah started all this crap, and the rest of the league has tried to use it to their advantage, and now it's become a propaganda circus.

Maybe one day someone will clue in that all this does is fire Murphy up to dominate even more than he does.
Exactly
TheLionKing
Hall of Famer
Posts: 25542
Joined: Sat Feb 19, 2005 10:13 pm
Location: Vancouver

This thread has gone 180 :lol:
User avatar
joesports
All Star
Posts: 443
Joined: Sat Sep 01, 2007 9:35 am
Location: Section 241 with a great view

TheLionKing wrote:This thread has gone 180 :lol:
You're right... :lol:

Back to Murphy (and the rest of our o-line) , it will be interesting to see if the officials decide to be throwing flags if our guys look at the Stamps D in an "intimidating" way, or if the officials now realize that they should be treating all teams equally. :roll:

Can't think of a more interesting week, fine-wise, in the league recently. Seems they're trying to regain some authority.
User avatar
Luke
All Star
Posts: 325
Joined: Sun Jul 22, 2007 4:05 pm
Location: Yorkton

I listened to the Murphy interview on the BMac and Rintoul podcast, and I was almost ready to spit when Murphy read that statement from the league.

I honestly thought about whether Murphy, Jiminez or any other BC Lion offensive lineman was a dirty player, and didn't really know because I don't remember seeing anything really objectionable from them, with the exception of Haji-Rasouli on Saturday.

The fact that this smear campaign, mostly on the part of Eric Tillman and Jim Popp, has influenced the league the way it has is a disgrace. The fact that Mark Cohon has even fined him for being 'intimidating' shows an incredible lack of spine on his part.
TheLionKing
Hall of Famer
Posts: 25542
Joined: Sat Feb 19, 2005 10:13 pm
Location: Vancouver

Luke wrote: The fact that this smear campaign, mostly on the part of Eric Tillman and Jim Popp, has influenced the league the way it has is a disgrace. The fact that Mark Cohon has even fined him for being 'intimidating' shows an incredible lack of spine on his part.
Time for David Braley to pull some strings and get rid of the spinless Commish :wink:
User avatar
Luke
All Star
Posts: 325
Joined: Sun Jul 22, 2007 4:05 pm
Location: Yorkton

JohnHenry wrote:I think the league's "intimidating" fine on Murphy was for when he held Chick down and had his arm cocked threatening to punch him...which is outside the normal football play. It is one thing to be intimidating with legal football plays, but another to intimidate with threat of physical harm.
He also said Fred Perry was one of his biggest fans.
I guess that's why Murphy sent him that autographed picture before the last game... :wink:
Thats a good point. He probably was fined for that, but what about the letter he received after the Montreal game? What did he do in that game that was so objectionable? I was there live, and I don't recall seeing anything.

I just remember Jim Popp's sour grapes after his team got manhandled in one of the most one-sided beatdowns I've seen in a long time.
User avatar
Dan_Payne_fan!!
Hall of Famer
Posts: 3568
Joined: Wed Oct 02, 2002 4:57 pm
Location: Port Moody

WestCoastJoe wrote:Wally Buono vs Eric Tillman?

Ex-Alouette linebacker vs pencil-necked non-football-playing Geek?

Hardly seems fair.

Perhaps it should be a WWE handicap match.

Wally Buono and Maria vs Vince McMahon and Tillman.

Tillman is the handicap.

Sounds about right.

Still not fair, though. Buono and McMahon about even, but Maria could pound Tillman.

There is even a Wrestler name and outfit ready for Tillman.

In this corner ... Piss Ant (short form). Little Red-haired Piss Ant (long form). (I understand Pissant is the correct spelling, but, what the heck, ... creative license ...

Dictionary says pissant means: insignificant.

Sounds about right.
HA!!!! yeah Maria could pound the poo out of him
2012 Season Ticket Holder
Scottish Leos Fan
Starter
Posts: 104
Joined: Mon Jul 16, 2007 9:48 am
Location: Dundee, Scotland
Contact:

Re: Rob Murphy on Team 1040 this morning

joesports wrote:I just caught the end of this interview with Murphy. Anyone else hear it?

He said Wally's never told him to change his style of play. Also said he will likely be appealing his fine.

He also mentioned he told the commissioner that at the end of the game with the Riders, he and Chick shook hands. As in, no hard feelings, it's part of the game.

He did mention how frustrating it's getting for him with the officials seeming to look for a reason to throw a flag....one game, the official was reaching for his flag before Murphy even did anything. As Rintoul said, they're punishing him for being intimidating.

He's the kind of guy every other team gripes about, but would have him on their own team in a heartbeat.

A great guy.
:thup:
Exactly. It annoys me when everyone says that he is a dirty player. He plays the way the game is supposed to be played in the trenches, HARD!!!
Lets Go Lions!
wildthing
All Star
Posts: 387
Joined: Mon Jul 16, 2007 2:53 pm
Location: EDMONTON

Re: Rob Murphy on Team 1040 this morning

Scottish Leos Fan wrote:
joesports wrote:I just caught the end of this interview with Murphy. Anyone else hear it?

He said Wally's never told him to change his style of play. Also said he will likely be appealing his fine.

He also mentioned he told the commissioner that at the end of the game with the Riders, he and Chick shook hands. As in, no hard feelings, it's part of the game.

He did mention how frustrating it's getting for him with the officials seeming to look for a reason to throw a flag....one game, the official was reaching for his flag before Murphy even did anything. As Rintoul said, they're punishing him for being intimidating.

He's the kind of guy every other team gripes about, but would have him on their own team in a heartbeat.

A great guy.
:thup:
Exactly. It annoys me when everyone says that he is a dirty player. He plays the way the game is supposed to be played in the trenches, HARD!!!
he does play hard noone disagrees with that, now if he wouldn't get involved in the extracurricular stuff he might not have the "dirty" moniker. he has been ejected from a game and then fined at least once in each season he has played, that tends to tell you something, when there are players that go a whole career without ever being tossed out.
User avatar
Rammer
Team Captain
Posts: 22328
Joined: Thu Oct 03, 2002 6:04 pm
Location: Coquitlam, B.C.

Re: Rob Murphy on Team 1040 this morning

wildthing wrote:
Scottish Leos Fan wrote:
joesports wrote:I just caught the end of this interview with Murphy. Anyone else hear it?

He said Wally's never told him to change his style of play. Also said he will likely be appealing his fine.

He also mentioned he told the commissioner that at the end of the game with the Riders, he and Chick shook hands. As in, no hard feelings, it's part of the game.

He did mention how frustrating it's getting for him with the officials seeming to look for a reason to throw a flag....one game, the official was reaching for his flag before Murphy even did anything. As Rintoul said, they're punishing him for being intimidating.

He's the kind of guy every other team gripes about, but would have him on their own team in a heartbeat.

A great guy.
:thup:
Exactly. It annoys me when everyone says that he is a dirty player. He plays the way the game is supposed to be played in the trenches, HARD!!!
he does play hard noone disagrees with that, now if he wouldn't get involved in the extracurricular stuff he might not have the "dirty" moniker. he has been ejected from a game and then fined at least once in each season he has played, that tends to tell you something, when there are players that go a whole career without ever being tossed out.
What extracurricular stuff? He held Chick down after pulling him off our QB, if any OL doesn't remove a DL from trying to rip the ball from his QB while he is down, he would be put to task by the HC. Now if you are going to cry about the Braidwood incident, he at least gave back in an honest way, as he had come out of that game with gouging around his eyes. Or are you talking about the club motion on Perry, which was very close to legal, just a tiny bit higher than he is allowed to do. That is the only one that I have witnessed this season as a concern and that was only after Perry had taken a run at his QB, so it amounts to much like a pitcher in baseball tossing at a batters head in retaliation.
Entertainment value = an all time low
wildthing
All Star
Posts: 387
Joined: Mon Jul 16, 2007 2:53 pm
Location: EDMONTON

Re: Rob Murphy on Team 1040 this morning

Rammer wrote:
wildthing wrote:
Scottish Leos Fan wrote: Exactly. It annoys me when everyone says that he is a dirty player. He plays the way the game is supposed to be played in the trenches, HARD!!!
he does play hard noone disagrees with that, now if he wouldn't get involved in the extracurricular stuff he might not have the "dirty" moniker. he has been ejected from a game and then fined at least once in each season he has played, that tends to tell you something, when there are players that go a whole career without ever being tossed out.
What extracurricular stuff? He held Chick down after pulling him off our QB, if any OL doesn't remove a DL from trying to rip the ball from his QB while he is down, he would be put to task by the HC. Now if you are going to cry about the Braidwood incident, he at least gave back in an honest way, as he had come out of that game with gouging around his eyes. Or are you talking about the club motion on Perry, which was very close to legal, just a tiny bit higher than he is allowed to do. That is the only one that I have witnessed this season as a concern and that was only after Perry had taken a run at his QB, so it amounts to much like a pitcher in baseball tossing at a batters head in retaliation.
You don't get fined/ejected if you are doing regular stuff. its the extra stuff that gets you those penalties. He plays hard I never disagreed, but his history in the league shows continual disregard to stop when a play is done. I think the fact that he has been ejected and fined at least once a season shows that he crosses the line and is "dirty" to a point. You guys bring up the stats about less penalties for holding, roughing etc. but look at the the history of your team since Murphy and Jiminez have joined and I believ the scales are tipped by fines and suspensions after the fact, those are what define whether a player is dirty or not. One time hey everyone can have a bad day, but at least once each season is a trend that makes a very distinctive statement about the player.
User avatar
Rammer
Team Captain
Posts: 22328
Joined: Thu Oct 03, 2002 6:04 pm
Location: Coquitlam, B.C.

Re: Rob Murphy on Team 1040 this morning

wildthing wrote:
Rammer wrote:
wildthing wrote:he does play hard noone disagrees with that, now if he wouldn't get involved in the extracurricular stuff he might not have the "dirty" moniker. he has been ejected from a game and then fined at least once in each season he has played, that tends to tell you something, when there are players that go a whole career without ever being tossed out.
What extracurricular stuff? He held Chick down after pulling him off our QB, if any OL doesn't remove a DL from trying to rip the ball from his QB while he is down, he would be put to task by the HC. Now if you are going to cry about the Braidwood incident, he at least gave back in an honest way, as he had come out of that game with gouging around his eyes. Or are you talking about the club motion on Perry, which was very close to legal, just a tiny bit higher than he is allowed to do. That is the only one that I have witnessed this season as a concern and that was only after Perry had taken a run at his QB, so it amounts to much like a pitcher in baseball tossing at a batters head in retaliation.
You don't get fined/ejected if you are doing regular stuff. its the extra stuff that gets you those penalties. He plays hard I never disagreed, but his history in the league shows continual disregard to stop when a play is done. I think the fact that he has been ejected and fined at least once a season shows that he crosses the line and is "dirty" to a point. You guys bring up the stats about less penalties for holding, roughing etc. but look at the the history of your team since Murphy and Jiminez have joined and I believ the scales are tipped by fines and suspensions after the fact, those are what define whether a player is dirty or not. One time hey everyone can have a bad day, but at least once each season is a trend that makes a very distinctive statement about the player.
I will wait on the fine, he is going to beat that one. If you are going to suggest his ejection in the Eskimo game was a) warranted or b) without provocation, then you have missed the reasoning factor. That ejection was in retaliation, but it also let Braidwood and Abdullah know that they had better be prepared to answer their calling out, and actions. No problems there on that ejection, that was a mans reaction to a boys challenge.
Entertainment value = an all time low
Post Reply