sj-roc wrote:Thanks for the replies, MikeAK, but frankly I'm still a little confused. I was previously under the impression that it was some sort of technology issue, but now I'm not quite sure I see the subtlety that holds TSN HD immune from local CFL blackouts. I mean, I pay Shaw for (among other things) TSN SD, and the Lions can still black themselves out to me. I'm not sure why TSN HD should be any different. I suppose it might be a matter of TSN SD only being sold (AFAIK) as part of a very large package of channels, whereas TSN HD is sold as a single channel for individual purchase by itself in isolation (or a much smaller package at least). That would mean CFL blackouts pose a far greater negative impact on the value proposition of the TSN HD product as opposed to the SD product (and therefore also on Shaw's bottom line), even though there's nothing in the technology from preventing this scenario.MikeAK wrote:Outside of needing the HD hardware to view HD chnls you still need to order the HD programming. TSN HD is a specialty channel that people have to pay for in addition to the basic package. I don't know for certain but this is why I believe they can't black out TSN HD. It is a PPV chnl that people have already paid for. I know I would have issues with SHAW if they blacked me out from my TSN HD after I've purchased it with the understanding that all CFL games would be televised.sj-roc wrote: Really? I was unaware of that PPV status, so I stand corrected; I'm still stuck in the SD era in my household, so I was under the impression all this time that it was simply just another all-or-nothing channel to add to your cable package if you so chose, and that people could easily access whatever programming it offered without any further special arrangement.
Even if all of the foregoing is true, I'm still unsure why it leaves the CFL/Lions powerless to enforce local HD blackouts. Oh well. :surrender
It's definitely beyond me as well. I am no lawyer but I just have a hard time believing they can legally blackout TSN HD after having advertised and collected funds for a certain product. One of the main reason I order and keep TSN HD is so I can watch my Lions games. I live on the Island and can't get over for games like locals can. I do know that I tried to drop TSN SD and all of my non-HD channels last year because I never use them and the SHAW rep told me they couldn't drop TSN SD because it was part of that CRTC mandatory basic package that we all have to have. So you may think you are paying for TSN SD like I am paying for TSN HD but you really aren't. TSN HD is a specialty chnl that people are ordering separately from the basic cable package. This is why I think legally they wouldn't be allowed to do it... and if they did they would be refunding quite a bit of money back to customers because of false advertisement.
If there is a lawyer in the house or somebody with accurate information I would love to have them set the record straight. I do not claim any of my GUESSES to be fact. It is simply my GUESS as to why they didn't black out TSN HD along with the SD chnl.