sj-roc wrote:I've just been taking part in an in-depth, online sports fan survey where they want to gauge things like which leagues have the most devoted following, which leagues have more TV viewers than live attendees, etc. ...
I wrote the above in early May this year and I think this survey is the one mentioned in this TSN article:
http://www.tsn.ca/survey-habs-the-stron ... a-1.327906
Survey: Habs the strongest pro sports brand in Canada
TSN.ca Staff 12h ago
Is it Toronto's iconic blue Maple Leafs logo? What about the green wave that marks Saskatchewan Roughrider fans?
When it comes to the brand strength of Canadian professional sports franchises, according to a recent survey, another team tops them both: the bleu, blanc et rouge of the Montreal Canadiens.
An independent poll by Insightrix Research polled 2,700 Canadian sports fans - 300 in each of nine major cities - in what was called a "sports brand equity index." [sj-roc note: I don't think this regional breakdown is right; the report itself on Insightrix's website, which I discuss in more detail below, says that each city was weighted in the survey with a number of respondents that reflected the national population percentage of that city as per census data] Fans were asked questions regarding five key metrics: first team that comes to mind, respect for the team, perception of the most loyal fans, team popularity and stadium/arena atmosphere. Each of these attributes had an assigned weight based on their impact on the team's brand equity.
Fans were also asked to predict the outcome of the survey in each metric, which the company says gives a more accurate measurement of the brand's strength.
The Canadiens came out on top, with the Maple Leafs second and the Roughriders third. Toronto's Blue Jays and Raptors finished fourth and fifth, respectively.
Mario Caceres, senior research executive for Insightrix, discussed the Maple Leafs' high placement on the list despite the club's lack of recent success on the ice.
"It's amazing to see a team that has not won anything in such a long time come in second across Canada," he said. "Winning helps, but it's not the only factor a team's brand should focus on."
Of the 10 spots on the list, six were taken by NHL teams, with the Edmonton Oilers the only franchise left off. The Montreal Alouettes were the only CFL team besides the Roughriders to make the list.
The complete list is below:
1. Montreal Canadiens
2. Toronto Maple Leafs
3. Saskatchewan Roughriders
4. Toronto Blue Jays
5. Toronto Raptors
6. Winnipeg Jets
7. Vancouver Canucks
8. Calgary Flames
9. Ottawa Senators
10. Montreal Alouettes
Among CFL teams, only the Alouettes and Roughriders made the top ten out of 21 Canadian pro sports teams (9 CFL, 7 NHL, 3 MLS, 1 MLB, 1 NBA) studied.
There's a much more detailed report on the website of Insightrix Research, the polling company who conducted the survey. You can find this report in a 27-page pdf (or more like a pdf-ised powerpoint file) at this link:
http://insightrix.com/wp-content/upload ... da-2.0.pdf
The TSN article doesn't mention it but the study also examined fans' views on 21 companies/brands who are widely recognised for their sponsorship of pro sports in Canada. I don't have much to say on this aspect of the study except to note that the popularity of Tim Hortons revealed in this study is consistent with that noted in the UVic study I posted to a recent thread in the pub section.
This pdf file shows several top ten lists, ranking teams by five metrics as noted in the TSN article.
Let's see how well the Lions did and what other CFL teams made the cut.
Spoiler:
most of these top ten lists contain the seven NHL teams, the Roughriders, the Jays and/or the Raptors and possibly one other CFL team, usually only barely making the cut. In the rare case where one of the NHL teams fails to rank, it's usually — as is the case on the overall list — the long-woeful Oilers.
TOP OF MIND TEAM RECALL: Thinking of all the five major sports leagues in Canada, regardless of the one you follow the most, what are the first 3 Canadian teams that pop into your mind?
• Lions didn't rank, only the Roughriders made the cut at #10 being named by 2.80% of respondents. Mtl Canadiens led the way at 23.30%.
TOP OF MIND TEAM RECALL:Regardless of the team/teams you follow, which teams do you think will pop first into the minds of sports fans across all Canada?
• Again, the Lions didn't rank, but interestingly the Roughriders ranked fifth in this list, named by 4.47% of respondents. Habs led here, too, at 31.64%.
PERCEPTION OF POPULARITY: Which of the following Canadian teams do you believe are the three most popular across the country? Rank the top three from most to least.
• Again the Roughriders were the lone ranking CFL team, placing fifth and named by 5.32% of respondents. Habs won again at 34.36%.
PERCEPTION OF POPULARITY: Which of the following teams do you think will be viewed by Canadian sports fans as the most popular?
• The Roughriders were named by 5.81% of respondents to rank fifth. The Alouettes sneaked onto the list with 1.75% of responses, displacing the Edm Oilers from a list that is otherwise very similar to that of the previous ranking above.
MOST LOYAL FANS: Which of the following Canadian teams do you think have the most loyal fans? Rank the top three from most to least.
• Roughriders ranked third at 12.45% with no other CFL teams making the cut. Winner: Habs, 27.78%.
MOST LOYAL FANS: Which of the following teams do you think will be selected by Canadian sports fans as having the most loyal fans?
• Roughriders again ranked third at 13.88%, again the only CFL entrant. Winner: Habs, 28.61%.
STADIUM/ARENA ATMOSPHERE: Which of the following Canadian teams do you think have the best stadium/arena atmosphere? Rank the top three from most to least.
• Here's where the Lions made their best showing. They ranked 9th, named by 2.55% of fans. Ssk led the way among CFL teams at 7.03% (ranking 6th overall) while Habs were again the overall winner at 27.71%. One suspects the Lions might have ranked even higher, or at least had drawn a higher percentage of responses, had the survey been taken a few years ago when we were still regularly drawing in the 30k's. By way of comparison, the Canucks were named by 5.74% of fans, good enough for 7th overall.
STADIUM/ARENA ATMOSPHERE: Which of the following teams do think will be selected by Canadian sports fans as having the best stadium/arena atmosphere?
• The Lions again ranked 9th, named by 3.02% of fans (more than in the previous question but I'm not sure whether the margin is statistically significant). Ssk ranked 3rd overall at 8.79% while the Habs were again tops at 29.34%. This ranking might reflect the Lions' strong showing in television ratings the couple seasons. The Canucks also ranked 7th overall here at 4.50%.
RESPECT: Regardless of which teams you like or dislike, please rate the following Canadian teams based on how much you respect them overall. (average ratings based on a 10-point scale)
• Ssk ranked 5th with a score of 6.88/10. Two other football teams made the cut: the Alouettes were 9th scoring 6.71/10 and the Stampeders came 10th at 6.64/10. Habs at 7.69/10 topped the list.
RESPECT: Which of the following teams do you think will be rated highest by Canadian sports fans in regards to respect?
• Ssk ranked 3rd, named by 7.38% of fans. Alouettes were the only other CFL team in the mix at #10, 2.07%. Winner: Habs, 37.04%.
The results of this survey might be discouraging in that the Lions come out in the bottom half of 21 teams in nearly all of these rankings, but it's interesting that within the CFL, the Lions rank 2nd on gameday atmosphere, both as ranked by the team's own fans and also as perceived across fans sampled in this survey. And as poorly as the Lions might have ranked, the Whitecaps — with their self-proclaimed best sporting atmosphere in the city — might take umbrage at not making the cut on any of these top ten rankings.
Also interesting that Cgy & Mtl made the cut on the respect metric, which IMHO is largely a by-product of the solid ownership of these teams and of what Hufnagel and Popp (and to some extent Trestman who is still fairly fresh in the minds of most CFL observers) have achieved in football ops in their respective cities. I think the Lions would have made the cut on respect and might have even outranked Ssk if this survey had been done during the Ackles II era. The Eskimos might have also fared better on some of these lists in previous years before their slide into mediocrity that began under Danny M, from which they have only recently begun to re-emerge under HC Chris Jones.
Perhaps the most surprising thing about this survey is that the thread about it on the riderfans forum is only 11 posts long as I type (still on just its first page!) and even then they seem mostly concerned with how other teams ranked rather than engaging in self-congratulation.
Sports can be a peculiar thing. When partaking in fiction, like a book or movie, we adopt a "Willing Suspension of Disbelief" for enjoyment's sake. There's a similar force at work in sports: "Willing Suspension of Rationality". If you doubt this, listen to any conversation between rival team fans. You even see it among fans of the same team. Fans argue over who's the better QB or goalie, and selectively cite stats that support their views while ignoring those that don't.