Chap is not charismatic or warm. He is methodical, detached, task focused. Chapdelaine was highly regarded by Leo players as Geroy Simon, Jason Clermont, Dave Dickenson, and Ryan Thelwell and less so by Casey Printers, Ricky Ray, and Andrew Harris (but Harris was not happy with Khari Jones or Cortez either... and Harris had his best seasons with Chapdelaine)maxlion wrote:Chap should have a positive effect on the offense, and that might be enough to keep the wolves at bay for the last stretch of the season, even if the wins don't come.
I always got the sense that he just rubbed folks the wrong way, lacked the charisma to motivate and lead. And, truth be told, his record as an OC is not spectacular either. He's had some good years, but I wasn't sorry to see him go. Maybe it's his time now.
I doubt that Thorpe or Reed are bent out of shape over this. Calvillo maybe, because he put his authority on the line and lost, but I have a feeling that coaching may not be for him long term anyways. Chap's appointment is just a situational thing where Chap fit the bill perfectly as an interim guy. No guarantees for next year, even for Popp.
As a football fan I was a tough critic of Chapdelaine in B.C. in 2005-2006 and 2009-2010. Chapdelaine, during those times as our OC was a pass first, pure spread offence coordinator. He learned the pro spread offence under George Cortez and used the spread offence play book from the Calgary spread offence of the early 1990's. It was how Chap was trained and the offensive system Wally wanted to be used.
It was an offence that focused on execution. In the sometimes strange world of Wally, Chap called the plays and coached the passing game but Dorazio designed the running game. Chapdelaine left B.C. at the end of 2006, knowing that Benevedes was Wally's favored assistant but was brought back to B.C. in 2008, at the request of some key Leo players,
I was not a fan of the pure spread offence and still am not. I referred to Chap's 2005-2010 version of the spread offence as 'Chap Ball' (even though it really was not his offensive system) and often found it frustrating. The spread offence was primarily a pocket passing offence designed for a quarterback who can go through his reads quickly and throw with accuracy. It is not an offence designed for a mobile quarterback who can bootleg and throw on the move. It was basically a plug and play offence rather than an offence designed for the personnel a team has, including the style of quarterback.
Part way through 2011, with both our offence and defense struggling (we went 0-5 to start the season) Chap made significant changes to the offence.
Because our Leos have mostly used the pure spread offence under Khari Jones and George Cortez) I have to think that those were changes that Chap wanted to make himself in 2011.
Chap began to use more misdirection, more rollouts, more motion, more formations, more play action and throw to his back out of the backfield a lot more. Lulay, never a quick read pocket style passer, started to thrive with the adaptions. We went on to win the Grey Cup in 2011 and had the best offence in the CFL in 2012.
With Lulay hurt in 2013, DeMarco forced to play, Buck Pierce thrown into the mix, and our running game struggling with Dorazio's blocking scheme, Chap took all the heat. Dorazio made changes to the blocking towards the end of the season for the running attack, Stefan Logan was signed post mid-season, and our offence was revitalized. Lulay came back to play against the Riders in the playoff game but we lost a close one (our offence played well) and Stubler was gone and Chap and Buono parted ways.
The Riders hired Chapdelaine over Paul LaPolice and others in 2015. The Riders offence, with Chap leading them, was the best in the CFL under Durrant and Glenn but could not sustain that level with their third string quarterback.
Chap led Laval to its first ever Vanier Cup and turned that program around as a HC. Due to the length of his tenure as an OC in the CFL he has had some excellent years and a few not so good.
His offences with our Leos ranked Top 3 in 2005, 2006, 2008, 2011 and 2012. He had the best CFL offence in 2006 and 2012. Even in 2013, the season that led to his downfall, we were 4th in points scored, even with Lulay's injury plaqued season and playing DeMarco for 6 games. His only down seasons were in Edmonton in 2007 and with our Leos was in 2009. In 2010 (when we went used 4 quarterbacks) our offence was 4th in the CFL.
I consider Mark Trestmann, Chapdelaine, along with HC John Hufnagel as the coaches who have made the most changes to the pure spread offence that dominated CFL offensive thinking for so long.
Trestman integrated a West Coast flavor to the CFL spread offence. He used multiple formations and a complex, quick-rhythm passing attack complemented by a diverse screen package as the basis of his offence in Montreal. Chapdelaine introduced a lot of different personell packages, misdirection, motion, and tight end sets to B.C. in 2011, in his new version of offence that I termed Jaques Ball.
Hufnagel re-introduced a dominant running attack back to the CFL as HC in Calgary. The former Calgary OC, who had introduced the spread offence to the CFL also focused on drafting and developing offensive lineman, introducing innovative blocking schemes, and creating new ways to exploit CFL zone defenses with his passing game.
I believe Chap will make positive changes to Montreal's offence and will improve things in Montreal for the remainder of the season. That may or may not lead to more wins there. I believe Chap is a better offensive coordinator than George Cortez or Khari Jones. Khari Jones really benefits from having a quarterback like Jennings who can make all the throws and has great poise in the pocket. There is nothing innovative about Khari Jones offence here in B.C. It's very vanilla.
I don't think it was Popp's call in Montreal to relinquish the HC duties. While he participated In the decision of Chap's hiring the owners were very involved and led the process.
No matter who is hired in Montreal as HC next year, its an issue going forward. If Thorpe is snubbed (and he was forced to remain in Montreal this year due to his contract), I can't see him being happy there next season. Cavillo saw himself as the heir apparent to the Head Coaching role and now he has Chap, his former assistant, as his HC and making changes to 'his' offence. Reed, as a former HC would view himself as having been the most qualified for the Interim HC job and can't be happy. Montreal owners said Cavillo, Thorpe and Reed would be able to apply next season for the HC job, in part to keep their options open but also in part so that they would not be too disgruntled for the remainder of this season.
Popp has been relieved of his duties as HC and owners can't be happy with his decision to become the HC for the fourth time and really mess it up this time. Popp may or may not be in Montreal next year.
It's a dogs breakfast.